| Platinum | Auntie Aldoo's Kitchen |
| Gold | Cookie Bar |
| Silver | Sample Bakes |
| Bronze | The Pantry |
| Top Pick | Acorn and Oak Coffee Company |
| Top Pick | Christine's Bake Shop |
| Top Pick | Cookies By Kathy |
| Top Pick | Crumbs & Co. |
| Top Pick | Crumbs Cookie Company |
| Top Pick | TLC Bakery |