| Platinum | Paper Heroes - Comic Book Lounge & Collectibles |
| Gold | Visibly Delighted-Games and Novelty Boutique |
| Silver | Mastermind Toys |
| Bronze | Toys "R" Us |
| Top Pick | Brimstone Games |
| Top Pick | Cartoon Kingdom |
| Top Pick | Milks and Honey Crochet |
| Top Pick | Rogues Gallery Comics |
| Top Pick | Siblings Consignment Shop |
| Top Pick | The Game Md |