| Platinum | Spago - Trattoria & Pizzeria |
| Gold | The Cook's Shop |
| Silver | Piccolo's |
| Bronze |
Vito's Pizzeria
|
| Top Pick | Casa Mia Ristorante |
| Top Pick | Koolini's Italian Eatery |
| Top Pick | Mamas Place Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Mettawas Station Mediterranean Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Mezzo Ristorante & Lounge |
| Top Pick | Riccardo's Italian Restaurant |
